Does Proposed Acquisition Raise Three-Tier Integration Concerns?

Generally speaking, and with some notable exceptions, the production, distribution and sale of alcoholic beverages in the United States are divided among three tiers, with ownership of producers, distributors and retailers required to remain separate.  For example, in Maryland, where my firm has its primary practice, anyone with an ownership interest in an entity with a manufacturer’s or wholesaler’s license is prohibited from holding a retail liquor license.  Although the 21st Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, which ended Prohibition, leaves it to the individual states to regulate the sale of alcoholic beverages, nearly every state has traditionally mandated this division among the three tiers.

Because the three-tier system is such an integral and widespread element of liquor regulation in the United States, it was with great interest (and some puzzlement) that I read this press release announcing the acquisition by a North Carolina craft brewery of a publicly traded beer, wine & liquor wholesaler.  (Read more here)  I was furthermore surprised to see that a substantial shareholder in the wholesaler was itself a company that owned several large, prominent restaurant chains, and that this company would remain a shareholder of the combined brewery/distributor.  Thus, it would seem that the proposed sale would lead just the sort of vertical integration between producer, wholesaler and retailer that the three-tier system was intended to thwart.  Illustrating this fact is a telling quote from the CEO of the chain restaurant company:

“We look forward to showcasing [the brewery]’s craft beers in our restaurants and assisting with its regional distribution.”

There you go:  brewery owns distributor, which will be assisted in such distribution by a restaurant chain which is a large shareholder in the combined brewery/distributor, all in an effort to promote that brewery’s beers in those same restaurants.  While not a true “tied house” situation, it could have similar effects.

Given this stated intention to use the vertical integration of the three tiers to its competitive advantage, it will be interesting to see how North Carolina liquor regulators view the combination of and cooperation between these companies.  Moreover, as the combined brewery/wholesaler company expands into other states, it will also bear watching whether it is met with resistance from other state and local alcoholic beverage licensing boards, either on applications for wholesaler’s licenses by the combined brewery/distributor, or on retail liquor license applications by new outlets of the associated restaurant chains.

Liquor Laws Continue to be Big Focus in Montgomery County

In order to compete with its neighbor the District of Columbia, Montgomery County, Maryland, continues to strive to make itself a more inviting place for those seeking after-hours entertainment options.  As indicated in my previous post, a sizable portion of these efforts involves reforming the county’s laws regarding the sale of alcoholic beverages.  In case you had any doubt, however, as to how important these issues are for the county, a recent article in the Gazette newspaper notes that more than two-thirds (9 out of 13) of the bills being considered by the county’s delegation to the 2014 General Assembly relate to liquor licensing and other aspects of the county’s regulation of alcohol.

If you have any questions about how any of these laws will affect your business, how you might be able to take advantage of any proposed changes, or how you can play a role in affecting the outcome of any of these proposals, please do not hesitate to contact us.

“Nighttime Economy Task Force” Issues Recommendations

Earlier this year, Montgomery County, Maryland, created a task force of local civic leaders and businesspeople to address issues that could make the county a more inviting place for those seeking lively nightlife offerings.  On October 21, 2013, this “Nighttime Economy Task Force” issued its recommendations, many of which — particularly those changing county liquor license requirements — will have a direct effect on the restaurant and tavern industry in the county.  Among the most welcome recommendations for this industry are:

[continue reading here]


Morris Law Firm Helps Bring Spanish-based Restaurant Chain to Bethesda

The locally-focused blog Bethesda Now featured a story last week on the upcoming opening of a new Bethesda location for the Spanish-based restaurant chain 100 Montaditos.  The local operators, who were approved for a Montgomery County liquor license on September 19, expect to open in early October.  The new location on Elm Street, just off Bethesda Row in downtown Bethesda, will be the first U.S. location outside of Florida.

The Morris Law Firm is pleased to have been part of the effort to bring 100 Montaditos to Bethesda, serving as their alcoholic beverage licensing counsel and assisting them in all aspects of their liquor license application and liquor board hearing.